PDA

View Full Version : Help with knock



Fireblade893
07-11-2011, 04:54 AM
After my engine build (9:1Rc) i have 5-6 knock at 4300-4500 rpm at 14.7 psi of boost.
Before the engine build with stock engine (11:0 Rc) at the same pressure of boost and same ignition-afr kal i don't have any knock

Yesterday night i have try to retard the ignition in the Knock zone at about -3° and it's knock the same.
i have try with premium fuel (100 Ron) and it's knock same..

After this i have try to reduce the boost pressure with the boost control at 12.9 psi-11.4 psi and at 7.1 psi (wastegate spring) and the knock are the same.
Now i think it's a engine noise but why this noise??
At the idle and in normale driving the engine don't have any noise...

The build is:
- Wiseco 86.5 pistons rc 9:1
- Pauter Rods
- Honda Oem main bearing
- Honda Oem rods bearing
- new chamshaft chain
- new oil pump Honda Oem
- GT3582r Twinscroll setup with 2 38mm TiAl wastegate


For the specs of the engine , when i bore the engine i have set the clearance from pistons to sleeve at 0.0031 "..

I have check for the Pauter Rods to sleeve clearance and it's ok, about 0.19 "

Anyone have this noise engine with pauter rods and wiseco pistons?
I attach the datalog with the Knock..

PetefromtheStreets
07-12-2011, 02:03 PM
Are you sure it's actual detonation that's occurring or wether it's just engine noise. My knock sensor goes off randomly and I'm positive it's not detonation. Either that or here's another....what's your fuel pressure? Any upgrades to the fuel system?

Where does your vtec engage? Around 4000rpm? Could be the pop of vtec causing your noise.

Fireblade893
07-16-2011, 09:51 PM
Ok, i have pistons slap at cold engine...can this is the problem that create noise?

Cold engine

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLFOh8OPmlQ

hot engine

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdzoOQGThPI

I attach the datalog..

For the fuel system is the returnless stock Honda with aeromotive fuel pump and ID1000 injector

Si Speed 317
07-17-2011, 12:11 PM
Asked a friend, here's his response:

Ask him how he's determining it's knocking? Via the knock sensor? If so, tell him the stock knock sensor is absolutely worthless on any built motor, and if he is absolutely certain everything is mechanically sound, he just needs to get a good tune on the car. I've tuned several built motors and as soon as you start modifying the internals, you change the engine harmonics and the knock sensor flips a *****.

PetefromtheStreets
07-17-2011, 01:12 PM
^^That's exactly what I was getting at^^

That's your best answer.

Fireblade893
07-17-2011, 07:13 PM
Ok, i have read a lot on the forum about the Honda Knock sensor..
I want to try a test with a C16 race fuel with the same Kal..if the knock are the same are ghost knock or engine noise!
With C16 race fuel it's impossible have a knock a 14.7 psi of boost and 14° of IGN!

Si Speed 317
07-21-2011, 11:37 AM
Are you sure about that?

Fireblade893
07-22-2011, 12:56 PM
Yeah i'm sure about that.
I have try with C16 race fuel and the noise/knock on the datalog are exact the same!
Now i made test for re-calibrate the knock sensor by the new feature Knock in the Kmanager 1.5.1

PetefromtheStreets
07-23-2011, 12:07 PM
If the same 5 knock count is there with race fuel then you have no worry of it to be detonation. plain and simple. Is that where your vtec crossover is? You have a built turbo motor. I have no doubt in my mind that its just too loud for the knock sensor to be properly effective.

Fireblade893
07-23-2011, 12:36 PM
Yeah are the same Knock/noise with C16 race fuel..
My vtec crossover is at 3300 rpm with a TwinScroll setup Gt3582R custom..

I attach the datalog with C16 race fuel..

Si Speed 317
07-25-2011, 11:01 AM
Hmmm... Definitely not actual knock

PetefromtheStreets
07-25-2011, 11:54 AM
^^agreed^^

Fireblade893
07-26-2011, 05:22 AM
Yes...they are not real Knock.
Now i'm working to the Knock parameters in new Kmanager version 1.5.1 with my friend engineering!
After few test (with c16, with 100 octane fuel and 93 octane fuel) now the knock sensitivity are setup with new value for record 1 knock maximun for WOT...

PetefromtheStreets
07-26-2011, 12:29 PM
Yes...they are not real Knock.
Now i'm working to the Knock parameters in new Kmanager version 1.5.1 with my friend engineering!
After few test (with c16, with 100 octane fuel and 93 octane fuel) now the knock sensitivity are setup with new value for record 1 knock maximun for WOT...

Glad y'all got it worked out.